JB: Goodwin Analysis
Kenton Slash Demon – Harpe
Andrew Goodwin, dancing in the Distraction Factory (1992)
carried out research into mainstream music videos and identified typical conventions. Applying his critical framework to music
videos such as ‘Harpe’ by Kenton Slash Demon, Jenna Mangulad, 2015 determines
to what extent the text is conventional.
Firstly, he stated that music videos demonstrate genre
characteristics. This video could be
categorised as being in the Techno House genre.
It is conventional in that it has an upbeat rhythm which mirrors the
tempo of the music video.
The cutting rate
of the music video is one of the most unconventional aspects of the production.
The song is relatively upbeat and joyful, but this is contrasted by the video
having a slow motion after affect with a relatively slow cutting rate to
emphasis the change in emotions on characters faces and to reinforce the euphoric
feel of the music video.
The post
production used throughout the production is also very unconventional. In many
examples of Techno House, animations are used to connote the dreaminess and the
hallucinatory feel of the often non lyrical music. Instead, an unconventional
story is used where a youth attempts to being life to a dead nightclub by
dancing with people, post production techniques are used constantly such as
slow motion and a ‘warm’ filter such as Hefe, contrasts with the Sierra, cold
feel of the previously isolated location of the bathroom. The slow motion
camera technique connotes youth rebellion in illegal drug use which is
reinforced by a close up the actors dilated pupil.
There are aspects
of the narrative which are very conventional of the Techno House genre, Tech
House is a very youthful up and coming genre. Stereotypically, therefore, it is
the teenager who is the inspiration for the music video, who in turn and one by
one inspires the older generations to get up and dance which results in them
having a much more entertaining time than before. This connotes the ‘infectiousness’
of the Tech House genre and how it can bring joy to anyone.
The performance is also quite conventional of the Techno
House genre, there is synthanaesia created by the ‘mood’ of the upbeat and fast
tempered track and the and the euphoric performance of the actor. It appears
that the youthful actor has consumed drugs, a conventional stereotype of the
Techno House genres audience, however, the actor appears very sociable and interactive
with everyone in the room and it becomes apparent that it is his energy and
vibe which inevitably brings up the rest of the room. Even the gothic actor who’s
iconography is to rebel against conforming to stereotypes finds himself
smiling, laughing and dancing due to the spread of love within the room.
This
song has no lyrics, but with the relationship between the audio as a whole and
the visuals it would seem that the visuals amplify the construction created by
the audio. We can tell this from the sequence due to the visuals building in intensity
at the same rate as the audio, for example as the song reaches its peak, the
epidemic of energy has spread and a longshot is used to show everyone in the
room dancing. However, it could be seen to be a relatively disjunctive video as
the links between the video and audio is minimal, it would not necessarily be
classified as a stereotypical choice of video for a song of this genre/type.
Goodwin made references to topics like
the notion of looking and voyeurism in his studies, it is particularly difficult
to link this to this particular video, due to the narrative not containing the
artist it is hard for them to connect with the audience through methods like
breaking the fourth wall, actors are used in this video instead. This
particular video there are no voyeuristic images given, the story line itself
gives an interesting perspective on gender, initially as the main character begins
to dance with one of the middle aged women, a close up is used to show her
friends disapproving on look on the situation as she fronts and looks disapproving.
This shows the regressive stereotype of teenagers as they are made to look
childish and immature. However, this is later contradicted as the older
generations appear to let their hair down so to speak. They are seen laughing
and dancing which links in to the music as this is after the ‘drop’, replacing
the lack of synthenaesia through aspects like lip syncing which may be more
suited to a more conventional and generic genre of music such as pop, as this
is much more of a niece genre this may explain as to why this theory cannot be
accurately applied to this theory. Music videos are a postmodern form of media which
implies that they often borrow and rework ideas from other texts and forms, characters
in this music video can be seen to be inspired from television programmes ‘This
is England’ and ‘Quadrophenia’ such as showing a form of intertextuality across
two media platforms.
Well done Jack, excellent work here, really astute analysis and understanding shown of how to apply a theoretical framework to a text, development of ideas and some detailed examples - articulately expressed too - high level work
ReplyDeleteThanks :)
ReplyDelete